State Farm and Allstate: Which is Better for New Drivers?
Picking a first auto policy is about finding what fits: your coverage needs, preferred service, and which discounts match your profile. State Farm offers simple, agent-driven support that many first-time drivers find reassuring, while Allstate highlights digital tools and driver-behavior programs. Both include standard protections—liability, collision, and comprehensive—but price them differently depending on ZIP code, vehicle, and driving habits.
The best way to compare is by quoting the same limits and deductibles with each insurer. Then add student, telematics, and multi-policy options to see how each factor changes the price. This helps you decide between a lower payment or richer features such as accident forgiveness and roadside assistance.
Comparing Coverage Options and Discounts
Both carriers cover essential needs for new drivers, but their savings levers differ. State Farm tends to lead with good-student and bundle discounts, while Allstate’s Drivewise rewards safe habits using real driving data. Budget-focused drivers should try both: sometimes a bundle wins, other times telematics yields better savings.
Get Auto Insurance Quotes
Personalized new-driver rates in under a minute.
Both companies have strong mobile apps for ID cards, claims, and roadside help. New drivers often appreciate quick guidance after small accidents, so test how each handles photo estimates and repair scheduling near you.
If you’re a student or recently licensed driver, prepare documents such as your GPA record or driver-ed certificate before quoting. It helps underwriters assign accurate discounts and can trim your first premium.
Get Home Insurance Quotes
Bundle home or renters insurance with auto for extra savings.
Quick Comparison: State Farm vs Allstate (New Drivers)
| Feature | State Farm | Allstate |
|---|---|---|
| Service model | Local-agent network; simple onboarding | Agent + digital tools; usage-based focus |
| Telematics program | Drive Safe & Save | Drivewise |
| Popular discounts | Good Student, Driver-Ed, Multi-Policy | Drivewise, Good Student, Multi-Policy |
| Accident forgiveness | Available in select markets | Available (varies by state) |
| Claims & repairs | Photo estimates, preferred shops | Photo claims, direct-repair network |
Both insurers deliver full protection with slightly different tools. State Farm’s local support benefits first-time buyers, while Allstate’s digital focus appeals to app-first users. Test both to see which approach feels more natural.
Discount Eligibility Snapshot
| Discount | Typical Requirement | Who Benefits Most |
|---|---|---|
| Good Student | Minimum GPA or class rank | High-school & college drivers |
| Driver Education | Completion certificate | Recently licensed drivers |
| Telematics | Enrollment + safe driving | Low-mileage commuters |
| Multi-Policy Bundle | Auto + renters/home | First-time renters or homeowners |
| Pay in Full / EFT | Electronic billing setup | Budget-conscious policyholders |
New drivers should explore how each discount applies in their state. For even broader savings, review Safeway Insurance quotes to see how regional carriers price similar coverage.
Bottom line: quote both companies on identical limits, test telematics, and see how a renters bundle shifts your premium. The right combination can reduce first-year costs without cutting protection.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What discounts do State Farm and Allstate offer for new drivers?
Both include safe-driver and good-student savings. State Farm emphasizes bundles; Allstate adds app-based behavior tracking.
2. How can I compare quotes from State Farm and Allstate?
Collect identical quotes with each and enable telematics in both apps to see which offers lower renewal pricing.
3. Is it worth choosing State Farm or Allstate as a new driver?
Yes—each provides packages that work for first-timers. The best fit depends on your ZIP, driving habits, and comfort with digital tools.
4. Can I bundle auto with home or renters?
Absolutely. Bundling usually lowers your total premium and helps maintain stable renewal rates.